PDA

View Full Version : I couldn't wait any longer - launched the Simmons



Boataholic
10-18-2004, 04:53 PM
O.K. well here she is!!! Almost done, but I couldn't stand it any longer. I've working on her all summer and the

season is rapidly coming to a close, so I splashed her on Sunday. Ran great, no leaks :)

http://pic15.picturetrail.com/VOL571/2723553/5471714/70056377.jpg

http://pic15.picturetrail.com/VOL571/2723553/5471714/70056367.jpg

This is my first venture into Wooden Boat land. Thanks to all who replied to my earlier posts as I was working my way into/through this project. I learned a lot about how boats are built, materials, finishing etc.

Even though I didn't build this one from scratch it was a great experience for a first timer like me. Maybe the next one I'll build from the ground up.

For those who want to know the gory details of what I did, you can see some photos at the following URL that go along with the long-winded story below.

Photos (http://pg.photos.yahoo.com/ph/dp_ski/album?.dir=b9f1&.src=ph&store=&prodid=&.done)

I bought this 16' Simmons Sea Skiff boat from the a friend of mine on Cape Cod who knew the original builder on the Cape. My friend used if for the occaisional clam digging trip with his kids/grandkids. It didn't get a whole lot of use, but was in need of some TLC.

I brought it home, had a BBQ and convinced my friends if they wanted to eat they had to help me flip the boat. Once flipped I started scraping and sanding. I didn't take it down to the bare wood per the advice I got here for the paint on the sides of the boat was sound. The bottom I sanded down to bare wood up to about the water line, then the sides I just sanded reasonably smooth.

I reefed out any loose/questionable caulking between the joints/seams. Anything that was solid/secure I left alone.

The bottom was somewhat checked so it got a good dousing of CPES. After that I layed down a coating of a very flexible epoxy filler,"CM15", the yellow stuff in the photos. I got this from Progressive Epoxy, http://www.epoxyproducts.com/
I spoke to Paul numerous times about what I was trying to do and the CM15 looked like it would do the job. I was pleased with the results, filled in the checking and made for a tough but very flexible undercoat. The plastic containers I
mixed the stuff in I can squeeze and touch the opposing sides and the epoxy material does not crack and/or split. How well it will perform over time on the bottom of this hull remains to be seen, but I'm hopeful. After it was fully cured I scuffed it up with some scotch-brite pads to give it some tooth for the top coat.

I then filled in the small seams with liquid BoatLife and filled any larger gaps with the regular BoatLife caulk.

After that I then filled in any dings/chinks/guages with System3's fairing compound epoxy. This was good for me for
having never worked with epoxy in any large quantities this is premixed with micro-balloons. Saved me the hassle of trying to figure out which and how much to add to create fairing compound. Sanded down fairly easy but still pretty solid stuff.

Finally it was time to apply the topcoat. After reading countless debates here as to what type of paint to use, I went for the one that was repeatedly reported to be easy to apply yet gives very good results. So I went with the Kirby's
white semi-gloss for the hull, since I didn't take it down to the bare wood, there are still some minor imperfections in the hull so semi-gloss was a good choice for me. 3 coats gave it a good solid finish. Learned all about the roll & tip method of painting.

After than I needed to get a cooler full of beer to convince my friends to come over so we could flip the boat back upright. The flipping only took 15minutes, but they hung around for hours, well at least until the beer was gone.

So now it was onto the fore/aft deck and gunnels. I started to sand down the gunnels, when I thought they're not that big why not just strip them. So I broke out the heatgun. Well in doing so I found strips of mahogany on the inside of the gunnels, cool I thought that will look neat. Oh oh, thats means I have to varnish them, more new territory for me.

The mahogany altered my color scheme. I planned to paint the whole top deck and gunnels red with a blue rub rail. Having all that red next to the mahogany wouldn't do the mahogany justice. Since it was Friday before a 3day weekend I had time and good weather but I didn't have time to get another mail order from Kirby's so off I went to Lowes, sorry George. I thought I might find an off-white or Ivory oil base house trim paint. No such thing, all the trim paint is latex.

Hmmmm, but tucked up on the shelves I found Rust-oleum marine paint. I never knew Rust-Oleum made marine paint. Read the labels, looked liked it would work and they had the Oyster-white I was looking for so I bought it and the Rust-Oleum white primer. Went on very well, one coat of primer and two coats of top coat did it. The primer dries quickly but has some serious fumes, open the doors for this stuff.

Once the fore/aft decks and gunnels were painted I tackled the rub rails with the red Kirby's. Two coats and they were set.

Then the numbers, painted them with the Kirby's several days earlier. I screwed the number panels on Sunday afternoon and had her in the water 15minutes later. It was cold here in New England, but I didn't care had a blast, with a big smile on my face the whole time.

I'll finish up the mahogany trim this fall if weather allows and tackle the interior next spring.

Thanks to all who chimed in earlier and the companies below, I can safely say all the products below worked as advertised
and I had no complaints. But seeing how I'm such a newbie to this ignorance is bliss too. I guess only time will tell how well things last, but given that the boat will be under cover on a trailer and only get used 10~15 times a year, I'm hoping it will be years before the next repaint.

Kirby's Paint - for hull and trim, http://www.kirbypaint.com/
System3 Fairing compound which I got from Mertons http://www.mertons.com/index.html
CPES, Penetrol and BoatLife caulk from Jamestown Distributors
CM15 epoxy primer from http://www.epoxyproducts.com/
Rust-Oleum marine paint for the topside from Lowes, go figure.

Lessons learned;

Wow refininshing a boat is a lot of work, but fun too.
Building one must be even more work and more fun.
Read the directions carefully and mix thoroughly.
Don't try to rush it.

Oh yeah thanks to WoodenBoat magazine. Never knew about it until my project. Bought a bunch of issues. The informative articles and juicy photos kept me fired up for my project. Also went to the wooden boat show in Newport R.I. this past summer, that was great fun. Some real beauties there!!!!

Domesticated_Mr. Know It All
10-18-2004, 05:10 PM
http://media5.hypernet.com/ubb/icons/icon14.gif Great Job!

I love those Simmons boats :cool:

Donn
10-18-2004, 05:13 PM
Beautious! Well done! A very "work" looking boat.

Paul H
10-18-2004, 05:19 PM
Great job!

Sometimes building new is actually easier than re-fitting or repairing an old hull.

Kev Smyth
10-18-2004, 05:21 PM
Very nice- It sure doesn't look like a first effort. smile.gif :cool: I bet it scoots right along with that "20" too! :D

dmede
10-18-2004, 05:33 PM
First off, great job. Boat looks fantastic.

Second, are you sure thats a Simmons Sea Skiff? From the pics I can see that it has a totally flat bottom, no v shaped entry at the bow (major aspect of the Simmons design). It looks similar (in fact identical as far I can see) to the John Gardner semi-dory. Find his Dory Book and take a look at the plans for the semi dories. There are several sizes (12' 14' 16' etc.). The 16' or 18' plan shows a boat just like yours.

Ive spent many hours looking at those semi-dory lines thinking what a nice boat they would make. If yours is in fact a semi-dory than I can see I was right, they make a fantastic boat.

Enjoy,
Dave

[ 10-18-2004, 06:35 PM: Message edited by: dmede ]

Hal Forsen
10-18-2004, 06:30 PM
Nice Job Boataholic.
I'm just a Simmons newbie but I know that he built many different sizes and the smaller ones were often flat bottomed, There is a flat bottomed little Simmons shown on Skiff Junkie's great site
http://www.simmonsseaskiff.com/
I'll be starting my Simmons 18' within the next year and am champin' at the bit to get rollin'.
HF

dmede
10-18-2004, 06:44 PM
Originally posted by Hal Forsen:
Nice Job Boataholic.
I'm just a Simmons newbie but I know that he built many different sizes and the smaller ones were often flat bottomed, There is a flat bottomed little Simmons shown on Skiff Junkie's great site
http://www.simmonsseaskiff.com/
I'll be starting my Simmons 18' within the next year and am champin' at the bit to get rollin'.
HFAgreed. In fact it may be that Gardner was drawing his version of this Simmons skiff. But I'm seeing other clues that tell me this is a semi-dory and not a Simmons. The stem head matches the semi-dory plans and so do the plank lines. The plank lines at the stem come together where as all Simmons planks Ive seen so far keep their width all the way to the stem. The Simmons have flat sides like a grid iron dory where as the semi has knuckled sides like we see here.

I'll take a closer look at my plans tonight when I get home, but I'm almost certain this is a semi-dory. Which in no way diminishes the great job done of it or the boat itself. John Gardners boats are very highly though of. I hope knowing the true nature of the boat will only enhance the appreciation of it.

Dave

[ 10-18-2004, 07:48 PM: Message edited by: dmede ]

Peter Page
10-18-2004, 07:08 PM
Very nice job. Are you sure it is a Simmons? I have never seen one with a flat bottom before. It should fly. :cool:

Hal Forsen
10-18-2004, 08:06 PM
I'll defer to those closer to the subject but I have to agree with dmede I've not seen any pics of a Simmons with the knuckeled-in hull.
Mr. Simmons made lots of boats and I've only seen them in photos so I'll let Skiff Junkie or Dave Carnell give you the straight poop.
Sweet boat regardless.
HF

mdevour
10-18-2004, 09:27 PM
Well whatever it is, it's a beauty! :D

Lots of character to it. Bet you'll be grinning every time you look at 'er.

You did good.

M.

Gary Lee
10-18-2004, 10:39 PM
I am building a Simmons. The bow does not look anything like your boat. I noticed the bow on your boat looks a lot like this hull design.

http://www.imagestation.com/picture/sraid118/pf0cd0a87050624e7fe8175996389a782/f8808b2f.jpg

Jim Pooler
10-18-2004, 11:07 PM
I think I found the plans that Dave was referring to. Here is a picture and link in case this one isn't big enough.
Gardner 19 (http://www.nwoffshore.com/images/gardner19_8.jpg)

http://www.nwoffshore.com/images/gardner19_8.jpg

[ 10-19-2004, 12:08 AM: Message edited by: Jim Pooler ]

imported_Steven Bauer
10-18-2004, 11:11 PM
I think you've pegged it Jim. Nice boat! :D

Steven

Bob Perkins
10-19-2004, 08:00 AM
Another Mass. Boat Builder smile.gif

Great Job!

Take Care,
Bob

Boataholic
10-19-2004, 08:21 AM
Thanks for the gracious comments and the hull identification. Since I'm just a novice at this I just assumed it was a Simmons. I knew it wasn't an original Simmons for it was built on Cape Cod in 1984. But now thanks to you guys I know exactly what it is. smile.gif

Thanks again,

Don

dmede
10-19-2004, 11:10 AM
Thats the boat Jim. In the Dory Book Gardner has a 16' version that is most likely the boat Boataholic has here.

Boataholic, if you want to know more about dories and your exact boat inparticular I'd recommend picking up John Gardners The Dory Book. It has great info on dory construction, uses, history etc. And for your boat it has the full lines drawings, offsets, detail drawing and point by point construction description. It's most likely the same info your boat was built from. It would be a good accompaniment to what I consider to be a fantastic boat. Amazon has it for like $25 I think.

I'm always going back and forth between wanting to build a Simmons or build the 16' semi-dory and until now I had never actually seen a completed 16' semi-dory. Lets just say my decision is getting harder and harder to make. Again, very nice boat.

Dave

Hal Forsen
10-19-2004, 11:46 AM
There are some photos of a nice Gardner 19 semi dory here http://www.imagestation.com/album/?id=3246355093
I like both designs but am going to build a Simmons.
HF

warthog5
10-19-2004, 07:25 PM
Boataholic Why the change in motors?

The boat is sharp. :D Don't let water stand for a long period of time on the Rustolum. My experiance with Rustolum Marine in lockers that held water was pock marks in the paint. :(

Boataholic
10-20-2004, 08:16 AM
The Johnson motor was what the previous owner had on. He wanted too much money for the boat and motor so we cut a deal for just the boat and trailer for short money. I found the Mecury in the local want adds for a 3rd of the price of what he wanted for the Johnson.

I wiped down the fore & aft deck and gunnels after the first run, pretty simple compared to the fiberglass and carpeted aluminum boats I've had in the past. Hopefully this simple maintenance will avoid the spots you refer too.

Dave Carnell
10-22-2004, 07:13 AM
Simmons built a lot of different boats. He told me he didn't like building the same boat over and over and he refused repair work on his boats, except for new bottoms on Corps of Engineers boats.

He built 16-footers and flat-bottomed boats. His granddaughter has a 16-ft flat-bottomed boat he built after he stopped building boats for sale. A few years ago I looked at one of his boats for sale here that resembled a Barbour runabout - transom-mounted outboard, bridge deck, rounded multi-strake hull.