Well Duh!..We already knew Congress was dumb

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • pefjr
    Humorist
    • Dec 2008
    • 14330

    Well Duh!..We already knew Congress was dumb

    Is Congress getting dumber?




    The Capitol Building in Washington, D.C.
    Think members of Congress act like a bunch of high school students? You might be on to something. A recent study from the Sunlight Foundation found that members of Congress tend to speak at about a 10th-grade level.
    The Sunlight Foundation analyzed every word spoken by every member of Congress on the floor of the House or Senate. Sunlight imported the words into a searchable database and then "ran them through an algorithm to determine the grade level of congressional discourse," according to a buzzy story from NPR.
    The finding: Congress is speaking at a lower academic level. Back in 2005, members of Congress spoke at a level equal to a high school junior. Now, the numbers have dropped off. Congress talks like a bunch of sophomores. Sunlight used something called the "Flesch-Kinkaid" scale to determine speech level. Longer sentences and words with more syllables equal higher grade levels. (Must be the Tea Party influence , right John OP?)
    Some interesting factoids from the Sunlight Foundation's study:
    —"Prior to 2005, Republicans on average spoke at a slightly higher grade level than Democrats. Since then, Democrats have spoken on average at a slightly higher grade level than Republicans."
    —On average, Congress members who are moderate speak at a higher level. Those on the far right and left speak at a lower level.
    —Don't assume you speak at a higher level than your representative. The average American speaks between an eighth- and ninth-grade level.
    It is tempting to see these results and say, "Congress is getting dumber," but a piece from the Atlantic suggests another theory. Perhaps Congress is just getting better at getting its points across. After all, why make an issue or speech or anecdote more complicated than it has to be?




  • Peerie Maa
    Old Grey Inquisitive One
    • Oct 2008
    • 62522

    #2
    Re: Well Duh!..We already knew Congress was dumb

    There is a correlation with an initiative here in the UK. Our last government, that socialist pinko commie Labour government under BLiar realised that we had an adult literacy and numeracy problem in our craft work force. Their solution was to enlist the organising and negotiating abilities of the Unions to set up learning centers in factories to assess those who had left education with low literacy or numeracy skills, and to provide learning assistance to improve the situation.
    One measure for literacy is the SMOG level. This confirms the comedians cliche about Sun readers:
    Analysis undertaken by Niace has shown average scores for newspaper editorials as follows:
    The Sun: under 14
    The Daily Express: under 16
    The Telegraph and The Guardian: over 17
    More information is on the NIACE website.
    where 14 roughly equates to US school grade 9, 16 equates to 11 grade and 17 to 12th grade.
    In briefing the Union reps about the initiative the level of literacy of the Sun was set as the bare minimum of an acceptable standard. It would be interesting to run the SMOG test on your politicos pronouncements.
    It really is quite difficult to build an ugly wooden boat.

    The power of the web: Anyone can post anything on the web
    The weakness of the web: Anyone can post anything on the web.

    Comment

    • S.V. Airlie
      Ancient Mariner
      • Dec 2006
      • 63914

      #3
      Re: Well Duh!..We already knew Congress was dumb

      In the 70's, I went next door to chat with my neighbor. I found him muttering and throwing pencils across the room. Basically he was disgusted. Now my neighbor was often asked to write for the National Geographic. he had the rough returned for corrections. Fifteen or more pages covered in red ink to be redone. apparently, the original article was written for adults not 8th graders.Hence automatic rewrite.He was not happy. Now if you think about this, many who read NG probably entered Congress around that time and many are probably still there. Think about it...

      Comment

      Working...